{
  "comparison": "Debatrix-based whole-debate, same N=21, original A-B versus Democratic-Republican",
  "data": [
    {
      "model": "GPT-OSS 20B",
      "dimension": "Argument",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.724",
        "p": "0.0002",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0011"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.601",
        "p": "0.0039",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0158"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "GPT-OSS 20B",
      "dimension": "Source",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.726",
        "p": "0.0002",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0011"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.608",
        "p": "0.0034",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0158"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "GPT-OSS 20B",
      "dimension": "Language",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.714",
        "p": "0.0003",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0011"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.588",
        "p": "0.0050",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0161"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "GPT-OSS 20B",
      "dimension": "Overall",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.728",
        "p": "0.0002",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0011"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.609",
        "p": "0.0034",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0158"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "DeepSeek-R1 32B",
      "dimension": "Argument",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.557",
        "p": "0.0087",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0116"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.175",
        "p": "0.4479",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.5226"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "DeepSeek-R1 32B",
      "dimension": "Source",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.587",
        "p": "0.0051",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0075"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.291",
        "p": "0.2012",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.2927"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "DeepSeek-R1 32B",
      "dimension": "Language",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.680",
        "p": "0.0007",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0016"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.529",
        "p": "0.0136",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0362"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "DeepSeek-R1 32B",
      "dimension": "Overall",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.601",
        "p": "0.0040",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0064"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.366",
        "p": "0.1029",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.1646"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Gemma 4 31B",
      "dimension": "Argument",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.675",
        "p": "0.0008",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0016"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.484",
        "p": "0.0260",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0521"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Gemma 4 31B",
      "dimension": "Source",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.466",
        "p": "0.0333",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0356"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.122",
        "p": "0.5980",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.6379"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Gemma 4 31B",
      "dimension": "Language",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.687",
        "p": "0.0006",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0016"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.634",
        "p": "0.0020",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0158"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Gemma 4 31B",
      "dimension": "Overall",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.674",
        "p": "0.0008",
        "stars": "***",
        "q": "0.0016"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.511",
        "p": "0.0179",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0409"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Qwen3 30B",
      "dimension": "Argument",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.435",
        "p": "0.0487",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0487"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.047",
        "p": "0.8401",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.8401"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Qwen3 30B",
      "dimension": "Source",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.487",
        "p": "0.0251",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0287"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.183",
        "p": "0.4259",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.5226"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Qwen3 30B",
      "dimension": "Language",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.617",
        "p": "0.0029",
        "stars": "**",
        "q": "0.0051"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.385",
        "p": "0.0848",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.1508"
      }
    },
    {
      "model": "Qwen3 30B",
      "dimension": "Overall",
      "old": {
        "r": "0.490",
        "p": "0.0240",
        "stars": "*",
        "q": "0.0287"
      },
      "new": {
        "r": "0.172",
        "p": "0.4572",
        "stars": "",
        "q": "0.5226"
      }
    }
  ],
  "source": "Current manuscript Appendix E, tab:orientation-whole16",
  "raw_p": true,
  "computed_new_analysis": false
}